Even Toronto’s Condos May Become Too Costly for First-Time Buyers

Even Toronto’s Condos May Become Too Costly for First-Time Buyers

In the Greater Toronto Area, where the average price of a detached home is well over a million dollars, condos have represented the final vestige of affordability for many first-time buyers.

Those days could soon be over, just as they previously passed in Vancouver, suggests BMO Senior Economist Sal Guatieri.

"The typical family in the GTA is priced out of the detached market, with condos the last refuge, and even that won't last long if prices continue to escalate," writes Guatieri in a recent client note.

From October to November last year, a household taking home the median-family income would have to put 20 per cent of its earnings towards mortgage payments for a benchmark-priced condo (assuming a downpayment of 10 per cent on a 25-year mortgage).

Yet typical households could get stretched to the brink if mortgage rates rose by 2 percentage points. In that case, these households would have to contribute 39 per cent of their gross income — the maximum ratio — covering ownership costs.

That's if condo fees, property taxes, insurance and utilities are figured in. "An income-chopping recession would also push this ratio higher," Guatieri adds.

The benchmark price of a condo in the Greater Toronto Area hit $381,500 in December 2016, having risen 15.2 per cent in a year, according to the Toronto Real Estate Board.

"Should interest rates rise sharply, even currently affordable condos could become too expensive for the median-income family," he states.

Observers have generally called for the Bank of Canada to stand on the sidelines through 2017 by keeping the key interest rate, which influences mortgage rates, at its current historically low level of 0.5 per cent.

Over this period, BMO predicts resale activity will droop in the wake of various mortgage rule changes announced late last year with the aim of cooling markets, including tougher mortgage stress testing.

At the same time, home prices will continue to rise, the bank predicts, though first-time buyers may have cause for optimism.

"Toronto's housing market should have another good year, but price growth will be much slower (and more sustainable) than last year," says Guatieri.

"Barring an abrupt shift in demand fundamentals — a spike in interest rates, a job-killing recession or a reversal in foreign capital flows — the market should stay vibrant."